Meta-prompt quality — ship (4.4/5)
| dimension | score | reason |
|---|---|---|
| goal_fidelity | 5 | The meta-prompt strictly adheres to the GOAL of 'testing' and does not drift into unrelated tasks. It focuses on identifying testing-related repositories from the provided data and structuring the output accordingly. |
| capability_fit | 4 | The meta-prompt includes clear instructions for analyzing the data, identifying relevant repositories, and structuring the output. It grounds the task in the provided search hits and scraped content, avoiding gratuitous filler. However, it could explicitly mention handling cases where no repositories meet the criteria (though this is implied). |
| reasoning_transparency | 5 | The meta-prompt justifies inclusions/exclusions (e.g., criteria for testing relevance) and defines success criteria clearly. It also requires self-scoring with confidence values and grounded explanations, enhancing transparency. |
| actionability | 4 | The meta-prompt provides a concrete, executable plan with step-by-step instructions (analyze, identify, extract, note exclusions). The output schema is well-defined, and the constraints (e.g., 'test' validation) are actionable. However, it assumes scraped content is available for all repos, which may not be true in practice. |
| ambiguity_handling | 5 | The meta-prompt surfaces potential ambiguities (e.g., incomplete scraped data) and requires explicit notes about data limitations. It avoids guessing by grounding all output in provided data and requiring confidence scores for edge cases. |
Output quality — ship (5.0/5)
| dimension | score | reason |
|---|---|---|
| format_compliance | 5 | The OUTPUT strictly adheres to the required JSON schema, including all specified fields for repositories (name, url, description, metrics, relevance_to_testing, confidence, why_included) and excluded_repositories (name, url, reason_for_exclusion, confidence, why_included). Additional fields like validation and metadata are also correctly formatted. |
| accuracy | 5 | Claims in the OUTPUT are well-supported by the SOURCE DATA. Descriptions for 'oven-sh/bun' and 'microsoft/playwright' match the scraped content. 'cypress-io/cypress' is correctly identified as a testing tool based on common knowledge, though no scraped data was available. Excluded repositories are accurately justified. No fabrications are present. |
| self_score_calibration | 5 | Confidence scores are reasonable and vary appropriately. High confidence (1.0) is assigned where scraped data confirms testing relevance (e.g., 'oven-sh/bun', 'microsoft/playwright'). Lower confidence (0.9 or 0.5) is used where data is missing or reliance on common knowledge is required (e.g., 'cypress-io/cypress', 'aaif-goose/goose'). |
| completeness | 5 | The OUTPUT includes all repositories from the SOURCE DATA, categorizing them as relevant or excluded with clear reasoning. Metrics are provided where available, and missing data is explicitly noted. The validation and metadata sections add context without omitting required fields. |
| usefulness | 5 | The OUTPUT is highly actionable. It clearly identifies testing-relevant repositories, provides metrics for comparison, and explains exclusions. The inclusion of confidence scores and reasoning aids decision-making. Even with missing data, the output remains useful by transparently noting gaps. |
task
testingvalidation
- hard_constraint_test
- verified - the output contains 'test' in descriptions and relevance fields (e.g., 'test runner', 'testing framework', 'Web Testing')
- data_completeness_note
- Scraped data was only available for oven-sh/bun and microsoft/playwright; other repositories rely on titles and common knowledge, with no metrics for cypress-io/cypress and no data for aaif-goose/goose
repositories (3)
| name | url | metrics | confidence | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| oven-sh/bun | link↗ | stars: 94.9k; forks: 4.9k; commits: 16,475 | 1.0 | ▾ |
| ||||
| microsoft/playwright | link↗ | stars: 93.3k; forks: 6.1k; commits: 17,553 | 1.0 | ▾ |
| ||||
| cypress-io/cypress | link↗ | stars: None; forks: None; commits: None | 0.9 | ▾ |
| ||||
excluded repositories (5)
| name | confidence | |
|---|---|---|
| storybookjs/storybook | 0.9 | ▾ |
| ||
| typicode/json-server | 0.9 | ▾ |
| ||
| localstack/localstack | 0.9 | ▾ |
| ||
| h5bp/Front-end-Developer-Interview-Questions | 0.9 | ▾ |
| ||
| aaif-goose/goose | 0.5 | ▾ |
| ||